This is not to say that my meal ended badly, it all went quite well. Let's just say papaya was just not as exciting to cook with as say...anything. But that was not about to stop me from trying to cook up something that would bring out the flavor of the papaya, but not rely on it to lead the flavor of the dish.
I actually happened upon my "tasting" a little by accident. I was testing out a papaya and mango salsa and testing griling papaya for fish tacos. This was on Sunday and realizing that I had gotten a little over excited about the shrimp, scallops and tilapia that I bought at Dirk's Fishmarket, I decided to invite my neighbors, Elise and Michael, over for dinner. They are kind people and I figured, even if it wasn't great, they would be happy not to have had to cook dinner that night.
But as it was all coming together I realized this was it! It looked and smelled wonderful. So when they arrived they were informed that they were to be my guest judges. They were in.
The side was a mango and papaya salsa. I pureed papaya with lime juice and then added chunks of papaya, mango, red onion, peppers and cilantro. The consistency was great with the thickness of the papaya puree and the taste was slighty sweet and slightly spicy. It was good. We had that with chips and then also used it with the main dish -- fish tacos.

I grilled papaya, mango, serranos, garlic, limes, and red onion on our charcoal grill outside in the Chicago winter rain. The smell was really beautiful with all those flavors mixing togeher in the grill basket. I displayed the meal on my beautiful (and large) cutting board. It was a create your own taco kind of display. It included the grilled fruit and veggies, grilled shrimp, sauteed scallops and tilapia, fresh cilantro, lemons and avacado. It was really lovey.


And the judges said...
Husband John: 16
Daughter Kellan:17
Guest Judges combined score: 17
And here a few pics of my happy guests.



And with that I say "buh-bya papaya".